Grade 5 · Unit 8: Share your views

A commentary on an issue

Should phones be allowed in school?

Many schools have rules about phones.

Read a commentary

Read this commentary written for the school newsletter.

Phones in school: my view

by a Grade 5 learner

Many families are debating whether learners should be allowed to bring mobile phones to school. In my view, phones should be allowed, but switched off during lessons.

Firstly, phones help families stay in touch. If a bus is late or there is a flood, parents need to reach their children.

Secondly, phones can be useful for learning when teachers allow them, for example to photograph experiments.

However, phones can distract learners, and some people use them unkindly. Therefore, clear rules are essential: phones stay off in lessons and are never used to share photos without permission.

In conclusion, phones are tools. With sensible rules, they can do more good than harm.

Many schools have rules about phones.

Setting out and justifying a view

State the issue, then your view. Justify it with reasons and examples. Acknowledge the other side and respond to it, then conclude.

Justify your view with reasons and examples.

Formal letters and standard English

Formal writing uses standard English: verbs agree with subjects. Plural subject → plural verb: phones are, we were, rules do. Use the same structure to write a real letter – for example to your head teacher.

Verbs must agree with their subjects.

Your turn: Correct: The learners was very happy and the teacher were proud.

Key words

commentary
Writing that explains your view on an issue and justifies it.
justify
Give good reasons to support your view.
standard English
The form of English used in formal writing, with correct grammar.

Activity: Real-purpose letter

You need: paper or a computer

  1. Choose a real issue in your school or community.
  2. Write a commentary that justifies your view.
  3. Turn it into a formal letter to someone who can act on it.
  4. Check standard English: verb agreement.

Think and talk

What I learnt