Grade 5 · Unit 8: Share your views

Book or film?

The book was better… or was it?

Many famous books have been made into films.

Read the review

Read this review comparing a book and its film adaptation.

Review: The Jungle Book – book versus film

a review by InquiryMind

Rudyard Kipling’s The Jungle Book (1894) is a collection of stories, some dark and serious. Mowgli, raised by wolves, must learn the Law of the Jungle to survive the tiger Shere Khan.

Many film versions have been made. The animated ones are colourful and full of songs, and Baloo the bear is a cheerful, lazy friend.

In the book, however, Baloo is a wise teacher who strictly teaches Mowgli the jungle’s laws.

The films are wonderful for younger children, but the book has more depth, danger and beautiful language.

Verdict: watch the film for fun – then read the book for the full adventure. ★★★★☆

Many famous books have been made into films.

Evaluate print and film

Compare characters, tone and plot. Evaluate: what does each version do well? Give reasons for your opinion.

Each form has strengths.

Suffix spelling rules

Suffixes starting with a consonant usually just add on: hope → hopeful. Suffixes starting with a vowel may drop an e or double a consonant: hope → hoping, sad → sadder. The suffix -ful has one l: wonderful, never wonderfull.

Different rules for consonant and vowel suffixes.

Your turn: Add suffixes: care + ful, care + ing, big + er.

Key words

adaptation
A version of a story made for a different form, like a film of a book.
review
A text giving an opinion about a book, film or show, with reasons.

Activity: Book versus film review

You need: a book you have read and seen as a film

  1. Compare characters, setting, tone and ending.
  2. Write a review with an introduction, comparison and verdict.
  3. Use at least three words with suffixes, spelt correctly.
  4. Give star ratings for both versions.

Think and talk

What I learnt