Grade 5 · Unit 5: Tell me how

Clear and precise

Would a stranger understand your instructions?

Clear directions help visitors find their way.

Read two sets of instructions

Two learners wrote directions from the school gate to the library. Evaluate them.

Two sets of directions

by InquiryMind

Version A:

Go in and turn a bit and go up the stairs and it’s there somewhere near the other room.

Version B:

1. Walk through the main gate and follow the path for 20 metres.

2. Turn left at the blue notice board.

3. Climb the stairs to the first floor.

4. The library is the second door on your right, with a sign saying LIBRARY.

Clear directions help visitors find their way.

Evaluate purpose, style, clarity, organisation

Evaluate any non-fiction text by four things: purpose, style, clarity, organisation. Version B is precise: 20 metres, the blue notice board. Vague words like “a bit” and “somewhere” confuse readers.

Judge texts by purpose, style, clarity and organisation.

Peer evaluation

When you evaluate a partner’s writing, be specific and kind. Give two strengths and one clear suggestion. Then evaluate your own writing in the same way.

Evaluate your own and others’ writing kindly and helpfully.

Your turn: Give one “wish” for Version A.

Key words

evaluate
Judge how good something is, with reasons.
clarity
How clear and easy to understand something is.
precise
Exact and accurate.

Activity: Direction test

You need: paper

  1. Write directions from your classroom to another place in school.
  2. Swap with a partner. They follow them exactly.
  3. Give two stars and a wish.
  4. Improve your directions and evaluate the new version.

Think and talk

What I learnt