Grade 5 · Unit 1: There’s a lesson in that

Discussion forum

Is it ever right to trick someone?

Good discussions need everyone to play a part.

Read the forum rules

Read how a discussion forum works.

Discussion forum: roles

by InquiryMind

Question: Is it ever right to trick someone?

Chair – introduces the question, invites speakers, keeps time.

Speakers – give views in extended turns, with reasons and examples.

Questioner – asks questions to dig deeper: “What if…?” “Why do you think…?”

Note-taker – records key points.

Summariser – sums up the main ideas at the end.

Good discussions need everyone to play a part.

Ask questions to deepen thinking

Questions help ideas grow. “What if the trick saved someone’s life?” makes everyone think again. Ask to understand, not to win.

Good questions develop ideas.

Speak at length, listen with purpose

In an extended turn, state your view, explain, give an example and conclude. Listen purposefully and respond to what others say. Follow guidance from the chair.

Extended turns need preparation.

Your turn: Write a “What if…?” question for the forum.

Key words

forum
A meeting where people discuss a topic.
role
A job you do in a group.
extended turn
Speaking at length to develop an idea.

Activity: Run a forum

You need: role cards, a timer

  1. Give out roles: chair, speakers, questioner, note-taker, summariser.
  2. Hold a 10-minute forum on the question.
  3. Swap roles and discuss a new question: “Is flattery ever kind?”
  4. Reflect: what makes a discussion good?

Think and talk

What I learnt