Grade 4 · Unit 8: Food for thought

Class debate

“This house believes homework should be banned.”

Debates help us think about different sides.

Read the debate transcript

Read part of a class debate.

Debate: Should homework be banned?

by InquiryMind

CHAIR: Today’s motion is “Homework should be banned.” First speaker, please.

RAFI: Homework takes away time for play, family and sleep. Children need rest to learn well.

MAYA: I understand Rafi’s point, but homework helps us practise what we learnt. Without practice, we forget.

RAFI: That’s a fair point. Maybe homework could be shorter?

MAYA: I agree that it should not be too long. Perhaps 20 minutes is enough.

CHAIR: So both sides agree homework should be shorter. Thank you.

Debates help us think about different sides.

Listen for the gist

Listen carefully for the gist – the main points. Respond to their ideas with relevant comments and questions. Suggest solutions that build on both views.

Understand the main points before responding.

Disagree politely

Respect the speaker, even when you disagree. Use polite phrases to challenge an opposing view. Ask questions to understand before you argue.

Deal politely with opposing views.

Your turn: Respond politely: “Football is the only good sport.”

Key words

debate
A formal discussion where two sides argue about a topic.
opposing view
An opinion that is different from yours.
gist
The main idea of what someone says.

Activity: Hold a debate

You need: a motion, two teams, a chair

  1. Choose a motion: “All schools should have a vegetable garden.”
  2. Teams prepare three points each.
  3. Debate: listen, take notes on the gist, respond politely.
  4. End by suggesting a solution both sides could accept.

Think and talk

What I learnt