Grade 4 · Unit 10: Grammar and punctuation

Commas that help meaning

Let’s eat, Grandma! (not “Let’s eat Grandma!”)

Investigate: one comma, big difference

Read the two sentences aloud. What is the difference? Read the recipe. Find every comma. What job is each one doing?

Making jhal muri

by InquiryMind

First, put puffed rice in a bowl.

Add chopped onion, chilli, tomato and peanuts.

After mixing well, pour in a little mustard oil.

Taste it, Mina, and add salt if you need it.

A comma can change the meaning.

Four comma jobs

A comma tells the reader to pause briefly. Use one after a fronted adverbial: In the morning, we… Use one after a fronted clause: When it rained, we… Use commas around the name of the person you are speaking to.

Commas make meaning clear.

Fix it

  1. After school we played cricket.
  2. After school is a fronted adverbial.
  3. After school, we played cricket.

Do not overdo it

Do not put commas everywhere. A comma alone cannot join two sentences. Use a full stop or a joining word. Read aloud: put a comma where meaning needs a pause.

Commas cannot join two full sentences alone.

Your turn: Add commas: Yes Raju after lunch we will go.

Key words

clause
A group of words with a verb.
fronted adverbial
Words that tell when, where or how, put at the start of a sentence.

Activity: Comma rescue

You need: sentence strips, comma cards

  1. Read each sentence aloud.
  2. Place comma cards where they help meaning.
  3. Explain each comma’s job to a partner.
  4. Write your own recipe using all four comma jobs.

Think and talk

What I learnt