Grade 4 · Unit 1: Story time

The dilemma

What would you do if you found someone else’s money?

Bus seats sometimes hide lost things.

Read the story

Read the story. Think about what Farhan feels at each moment.

The five-hundred-taka note

by InquiryMind

The bus was almost empty when Farhan saw it: a five-hundred-taka note, folded small, tucked down the side of the seat.

His heart thumped. Five hundred taka! That was the football boots he had been dreaming of for months.

He glanced at the old woman two seats ahead. She was searching her bag, again and again, her fingers trembling.

Farhan looked at the note. He looked at the woman’s worried face. He thought about the boots.

The bus stopped. The woman stood up slowly, still searching.

Farhan took a deep breath. “Excuse me, Aunty,” he said. “I think you dropped this.”

The smile she gave him was worth more than any boots.

Bus seats sometimes hide lost things.

Reading between the lines

The story never says “Farhan was tempted”. The meaning is implicit. Clues like “his heart thumped” let us infer feelings. Good readers explore what the writer suggests as well as what is said.

Implicit meanings are hinted at, not stated.

Your response

Give your personal response: how did the story make you feel? Link it to your own life: have you faced a dilemma like this? Take a viewpoint: was Farhan right? Give reasons.

Link the story to your own experience.

Your turn: Write one sentence giving your opinion of Farhan, with a reason.

Key words

dilemma
A difficult choice between two options.
implicit
Suggested but not said directly.
viewpoint
The way a person sees and thinks about something.

Activity: Conscience alley

You need: the class in two lines

  1. One person walks between the lines as Farhan.
  2. One line gives reasons to keep the money; the other to give it back.
  3. Farhan decides and explains why.
  4. Write a paragraph giving your own viewpoint.

Think and talk

What I learnt